Select Page

Heresy and Truth

George Gillespie (1613-1648)

Today, many Christians are turning back to the puritans to, “walk in the old paths,” of God’s word, and to continue to proclaim old truth that glorifies Jesus Christ. There is no new theology. In our electronic age, more and more people are looking to add electronic books (ePubs, mobi and PDF formats) to their library – books from the Reformers and Puritans – in order to become a “digital puritan” themselves. Take a moment to visit Puritan Publications (click the banner below) to find the biggest selection of rare puritan works updated in modern English in both print form and in multiple electronic forms. There are new books published every month. All proceeds go to support A Puritan’s Mind.

“It is the privilege of the new Jerusalem which is above, that there is no temple therein, Rev. 21.22, no ministry, no preaching, no sacraments in heaven, but God shall be all in all. An immediate enjoyment of God in this world without ordinances is but a delusion. In the church triumphant prophecies shall fail, 1 Cor. 13.8; but in the church militant, “despise not prophesyings,” 1 Thess. 5.20.

Gillespie answers how one would know the difference between the two.

It is good divinity to maintain that skepticism, fluctuation and wavering, concerning those things which God has revealed to be believed or done by us, is a sin; and to be firm, fixed and established in the faith, is a duty commanded. I shall first prove it to be so; then give reasons for it; and, thirdly, some helps to this duty, and preservatives against this sin.

For proof of the thing, somewhat might be said from the very light of nature; for “hath a nation changed their gods?” Jer. 2:11. Religion has the very name of it, a religando [binding fast], so far it is a relaxando [loosening]. The heathen Greeks called a lubricious and inconstant man, [Gk.] Antropos Euripos [a tidal man]. They said also that he who errs or miscarries in his religion does [Gk.] ek tetrimmenas kulikos piein, drink out of a bored or foraminous cup [a leaking cup]. How firm and constant have heathen philosophers been in maintaining their opinions! They could not only displease their friends, amicus [friend] Plato, etc., but suffer the heaviest things for their opinions. And shall not we much more hold fast the profession of the true faith? Zonarus (Annals, tom. 3), in the reign of Michael the Emperor, the son of Theophilus, tells us, that when the sister of the Prince of Bulgaria became a Christian, and the Prince also, by her means, converted, the Bulgarians conspired against him for this change of religion. This diabolical steadfastness of theirs provoked him to a true Christian steadfastness, till, by God’s assistance and blessing, they were made to turn to him, but he turned not again to them. The Athenians impeached Socrates, upon his life, for going about to innovate and change their religion.

But, to set aside nature’s light, there is not any of the primitive churches to which the apostles wrote epistles, but they were expressly warned, either positively, to stand fast in the faith, to hold their profession; or, negatively, to beware of, and to avoid false teachers, and not to be carried about with diverse and strange doctrines. Now it must be not only a truth, but a most special and necessary truth, which the apostles thought fit to press upon the churches in all their epistles written to them. See Rom. 16:17-18; 1 Cor. 16:13; 2 Cor. 11:3-4; Gal. 1:6, 8; Eph. 4:14; Phil. 3:2, 18; Col. 2:6-8; 2 Thess. 2:2-3; Heb. 10:23; 13:9; James 5:19-20; 2 Pet. 2:1-3; 3:16-18; 1 John 4:1; Jude 3-4. All of these texts are full and plain as to this point which I speak to, and in that respect most worthy of our frequent thoughts and observation, especially at such a time when this corner of the world is so full of new and strange doctrines.

As for the reasons, take these: 1. If we be not steadfast and immovable in the profession of our faith, we frustrate (as to us) the end for which the scriptures were written. Luke gives us this reason to his Theophilus why he wrote the story of Christ’s birth, life and death, “That thou mightest know the certainty of those things wherein thou hast been instructed,” Luke 1:4. When Peter had mentioned the voice which came from heaven concerning Christ, he adds the certainty of the scripture as a greater certainty, “We have also a more sure word of prophecy, whereunto ye do well that ye take heed, as unto a light that shineth in a dark place,” 2 Pet. 1:19. A voice from heaven might sooner deceive us than the written word of God.

2. To maintain and profess the true doctrine, and the true faith, is, by all Protestant orthodox writers, made one, yea, the principal mark of a true visible church. Christ himself, John 10:4-5 gives us this mark of his sheep, The sheep “follow him (their shepherd), for they know his voice. And a stranger will they not follow, but will flee from him: for they know not the voice of strangers.”

3. If we once forsake the way of truth, and go into an erroneous way, we shall not know where to find our paths; we shall wander from mountain to hill, and forget our resting place. As one wave comes after another, so does one error come after another. As a canker spreads, so does error, 2 Tim. 2:17; “Evil men and seducers shall wax worse and worse, deceiving and being deceived,” 2 Tim. 3:13; which has made some, and I hope will make more, who were too inclined to the new doctrine and practices of sectaries at first, now to fall off from them, when “they increase unto more ungodliness,” and unto more error. And there is no end; one error breeds a hundred, and a hundred will breed ten thousand. What was it that made so many fall from the prelates who once joined with them? Was it not because they were growing from the old ceremonies to many new ones, and each year, almost, brought in some new superstition, and from Popish rites they grew to Popish doctrines?

4. If we waver and be led about with diverse and strange doctrines, then the prophecies which have gone before of the true church shall not be made good in us. It was promised concerning the church and kingdom of Christ, Isa. 32:4-5: “The heart also of the rash shall understand knowledge, and the tongue of stammerers shall be ready to speak plainly. The vile person shall no more be called liberal,” etc., that is, those who simply and rashly were led about with every wind of doctrine shall be so wise and knowing as to distinguish between truth and error, between virtue and vice, and call each thing by its right name. So Isa. 33:6, “And wisdom and knowledge shall be the stability of your times, and strength of salvation.”

5. Instability and forsaking the way of truth makes us lose much that we had gained, 2 John 8; all the comfort we enjoyed, all the good that ever our souls received of such a truth, such a cause, such a ministry, all that ever we did, or spoke, or suffered for the truth, all this we lose when we turn aside after an erroneous way.

6. It greatly hinders our spiritual comfort and contentment. Col. 2:2, to be knit together in love is one mean, and to have all riches of the full assurance of understanding to the acknowledgment of gospel truths, is another mean by which the apostle wishes the hearts of Christians to be comforted. It added much to Paul’s comfort that he could say, “I have kept the faith; henceforth there is laid up for me a crown,” etc., 2 Tim. 4:7-8.

7. We run a great hazard of our souls and our salvation when we turn aside from truth to error. It is said of the unstable, that they wrest the scriptures “unto their own destruction,” 2 Pet. 3:16. Like a man fallen into quicksands, the more he wrestles out the more he sinks. When the apostle has spoken of Christ’s purchasing of our reconciliation, justification and sanctification, he adds an if; Col. 1:23, “If ye continue in the faith grounded and settled, and be not moved away from the hope of the gospel, which ye have heard.” Not that our persevering in the true faith was a condition in Christ’s purchasing of these blessings, but it is a condition without which we cannot possess and enjoy what Christ has purchased; that is, he that falls away from the true doctrine of the gospel proves himself to have no part of the benefits of Christ.

Some errors are, in their own nature, damnable and inconsistent with the state of grace or fellowship with God, 2 Peter 2:9; so 2 John 9, “Whosoever transgresseth and abideth not in the doctrine of Christ, hath not God.” Sure it may be said of Arians, Socinians, Papists, Libertines, they have not God, because they abide not in the doctrine of Christ; so Gal. 5:4. Other errors there are, of which I may say, whatsoever they are comparatively, impenitency, and continuing in them, does condemn, whence it is that the apostle James reckons him who errs from the truth to be in a way of death and danger of damnation, James 5:19-20.

Now, the preservatives against wavering, and helps to steadfastness in the faith, are these: 1. Grow in knowledge and circumspection; be not simple as children in understanding. There is “sleight of men, and cunning craftiness, whereby they lie in wait to deceive;” so speaks the apostle of those that spread diverse and strange doctrines, Eph. 4:14; and Rom. 16:18, he warns us that they do “by good words and fair speeches deceive the hearts of the simple.” You have, therefore, need of the wisdom of the serpent, that you be not deceived, as well as of the simplicity of the dove, that you be not a deceiver, Phil. 1:9-10. Do not rashly engage into any new opinion, much less into the spreading of it. With the well-advised is wisdom. Pythagoras would have his scholars only to hear, and not to speak for five years. Be swift to hear, but not to speak or engage: “Prove all things,” and when you have proved, be sure to “hold fast to that which is good,” 1 Thess. 5:21; Matt. 7:15, 17. There was never a heresy yet broached, but under some fair plausible pretence: “beguiling unstable souls,” as Peter speaks, 2 Peter 2:14. “The simple believeth every word,” Prov. 14:15. Be not like the two hundred that went in the “simplicity” of their hearts after Absalom in his rebellion, not knowing anything, but that he was to pay his vow in Hebron, 2 Sam. 15:11.

2. Grow in grace and holiness, and the love of the truth; for the stability of the mind in the truth, and the stability of the heart in grace, go hand in hand together, Heb. 13:9. David’s rule is good: Ps. 25:12, “What man is he that fears the Lord? him shall you teach in the way that he shall choose;” which is also Christ’s rule, John 7:17, “If any man will do his will, he shall know of the doctrine, whether it be of God, or whether I speak of myself;” see also Deut. 11:13,16. Elisha healed the unwholesome waters of Jericho by casting salt into the fountain, 2 Kings 2:21. So must the bitter streams of pernicious errors be healed by getting the salt of mortification and true sanctifying grace in the fountain.

3. Be sure to cleave to your faithful and sound teachers. The sheep that follow the shepherd are best kept from the wolf. I find the exhortation to stability in the faith joined with the fruitful labours of faithful teachers, Phil. 3:16-17; Heb. 13:7,9. So the apostle, Eph. 4:11-14, from the work of the ministry draws this consequence, “That we henceforth be no more children, tossed to and fro, and carried about with every wind of doctrine.” The Galatians were easily seduced, as soon as they were made to disgust Paul.

4. Watch and be vigilant against the first beginnings of declining, against the first seeds of error, Gal. 5:9. It was “while men slept” that the enemy came and sowed tares among the wheat, and when he had done, went his way, Matt. 13:25. Therefore “watch ye, stand fast in the faith,” 1 Cor. 16:13; go hand in hand together.

5. Avoid and withdraw from the authors and spreaders of heresies and dangerous errors, Rom. 16:17; 1 Tim. 6:5; 2 John 10, 11; Phil. 3:2. He that would be godly should not use ungodly company, and he that would be orthodox should not use heretical company, unless he has some good hopes to convert some who have erred from the truth, and comes into their company for that end, James 5:19-20. I remember Chrysostom, in diverse places, warns his hearers how much they endangered their souls by going into the Jewish synagogues, and there was a great zeal in the ancient church to keep Christians that were orthodox from the assemblies and company of heretics.

6. Get church discipline established and duly exercised, which is ordained to purge the church from false doctrine, Rev. 2:14, 20.

7. “Lean not unto thine own understanding,” and “be not wise in thine own eyes,” Prov. 3:5, 7. Let reason be brought into captivity to the obedience of Christ, 2 Cor. 10:5. That which made the Antitrinitarians and Socinians fall away from the belief of the trinity of persons in the Godhead, and of the union of the two natures of God and man in the person of Christ, was because their reason could not comprehend these articles, which is the ground of their opinion professed by themselves. When I speak of captivating reason, I do not mean implicit faith. The eyes of my understanding must be so far opened by the Holy Ghost, that I may know such an article is held forth in scripture to be believed, and therefore I do believe that it is, though my reason cannot comprehend how it is.

8. Count your cost, and be well resolved beforehand what it will cost you to be a disciple of Christ, to be a constant professor of the truth, Luke 14:26-34; Acts 14:22, “Confirming the souls of the disciples, and exhorting them to continue in the faith, and that we must through much tribulation enter the kingdom of God.” This is surer than to confirm ourselves with the hopes of a golden age of prosperity, in which we shall feel no affliction.

9. “Search the scriptures,” John 5:39; Acts 17:11. Do not take upon trust new lights from any man, be he never so eminent for parts or for grace, but to the law and the testimony.

The upshot of all is that we ought to hold fast the profession of our faith without wavering, and be steadfast, and even immovable in the truth, and not to give place to the adversaries, no, not for an hour, Gal. 2:4-5. I do not mean pertinacity in the least error, nor a vain presumptuous overweening conceit of our knowledge, to make us despise any light which others may give us from scripture. Pertinacity is an evil upon the one hand, and to be too tenacious of our own opinions; but that [Gk.] kenotas [emptiness] and [Gk.] kouphotas [lightness], that levity, inconstancy, wavering, skepticism, is an evil upon the other hand. “Be not soon shaken in mind,” etc., 2 Thess. 2:2.

And this is the epidemical disease of the sectaries of this time, which I have now been labouring to cure. Their word is yea and nay, and not unlike to that which Sallust objected to Cicero, that he said one thing sitting, another thing standing. Yet it may be sometimes observed, that those who are the greatest skeptics and Pyrrhonians in reference to the common and received tenets are the most pertinacious and tenacious in tenets invented by themselves. I have read it observed of Socinus, that as he set at nought fathers, councils, and the whole current of ancient and modern interpreters of scripture, so vain glory made him to maintain stiffly and tenaciously any opinion or invention of his own, as if he had been infallible.

Men are sooner drawn from the truth than from error. Some are unstable in the truth, and unstable in error too; you may find among them annuas atque menstruas fides [yearly and monthly faiths] (to use Hilary’s phrase); they are of a new faith and a new religion every year, if not every month. Remember Reuben’s reproach, Gen. 49:4, “Unstable as water, thou shalt not excel.”

One sort of sectaries there is, indeed which will not engage to hold anything, but are known to believe nothing. These now pass under the name Seekers. Yet if one of the ancient fathers, or of the Reformers themselves who lived a hundred years ago, were now alive, they could tell us that these Seekers were, in their days, called Atheists; and, indeed, what other name is due to these nullisidians who are of no religion?

Offsite Banner Ad:

Help Support APM

Search the Site

Reformed Theology at A Puritan's Mind